Nihilism is as good as term as any to explain why our fucking failures of stroke associations do nothing to solve any of the problems in stroke for survivors.
This is pretty much fucking useless since the interventions are never described and you can't create a stroke protocol out of any of this.
http://nnr.sagepub.com/content/30/4/384.full
- Adebimpe O. Obembe, PhD1
- Janice J. Eng, PhD1⇑
- Janice J. Eng, PhD, Department of Physical Therapy, Faculty of Medicine, University of British Columbia, T325-2211 Westbrook Mall, Vancouver, BC, V6T 2B5, Canada. Email: janice.eng@ubc.ca
Abstract
Background. Despite the fact that social participation is considered a pivotal outcome of a successful recovery after stroke, there
has been little attention on the impact of activities and services on this important domain.
Objective. To present a systematic review and meta-analysis from randomized controlled trials (RCTs) on the effects of rehabilitation
interventions on social participation after stroke.
Methods.
A total of 8 electronic databases were searched for relevant RCTs that
evaluated the effects of an intervention on the outcome
of social participation after stroke. Reference
lists of selected articles were hand searched to identify further
relevant
studies. The methodological quality of the studies
was assessed using the Physiotherapy Evidence Database Scale.
Standardized
mean differences (SMDs) and confidence intervals
(CIs) were estimated using fixed- and random-effect models.
Results.
In all, 24 RCTs involving 2042 stroke survivors were identified and
reviewed, and 21 were included in the meta-analysis.
There was a small beneficial effect of
interventions that utilized exercise on social participation (10
studies; SMD = 0.43;
95% CI = 0.09, 0.78; P = .01) immediately after the program ended. Exercise in combination with other interventions (13 studies; SMD = 0.34; 95%
CI = 0.10, 0.58; P = .006) also resulted
in beneficial effects. No significant effect was observed for
interventions that involved support services
over 9 studies (SMD = 0.09 [95% CI = −0.04, 0.21]; I2 = 0%; P = .16).
Conclusions. The included studies provide evidence that rehabilitation interventions may be effective in improving social participation
after stroke, especially if exercise is one of the components.
Introduction
A World Health Organization1
report revealed that stroke results in the greatest burden of disease
among all neurological disorders (including Alzheimer’s
and dementias). There is an increasing number of
strokes because the North American population is aging, and a greater
proportion
of people than before are surviving stroke.
Unfortunately, not all patients are getting access to the care and
rehabilitation
they need to have the best possible outcome.2
Recovery of function in stroke patients is a complex process, which may be spontaneous and involve the effects of therapeutic
interventions.3,4
Knowledge about interventions that promote the best outcomes on
recovery may help optimize health care services. Successful
recovery from a stroke should result in a quality
of life and degree of participation in the community similar to that
prior
to the stroke event. There has been increasing
criticism of the lack of services and research on the long-term
consequences
after stroke. A BMJ commentary summarized
this sentiment: “Comprehensive national audits of stroke care show
alarming levels of neglect in terms
of chronic disease management and seem to indicate a
collective nihilism about the potential for altering function and
well-being
after the early treatment of stroke” (p 461).5
However, there is little consensus about the effects of rehabilitation
services for stroke survivors once they have left
the hospital and are living in the community.
Social participation is considered one of the most relevant and pivotal
outcomes
of a successful recovery.6 Individuals have been shown to be dissatisfied with their ability to engage in numerous aspects of participation, including
socializing, outings, and travel, at 3 months after sustaining a stroke.7 The provision of rehabilitation services after hospital discharge may be particularly relevant because it aims to promote
patients’ independence and reintegration into the community.
The International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) defines participation as “involvement in a life
situation”8 or as “the lived experience” of people in the actual context in which they live. Participation is a treatment goal in the
context of recovering from stroke and is known to correlate with domains related to quality of life.9 Using a content analysis involving 43 studies, Levasseur et al10
defined social participation “as a person’s involvement in activities
that provide interaction with others in society or
the community” (p 2148). Similarly, the Disability
Creation Process conceptual model defines social participation as a
means
of carrying out one’s life habits in one’s
environment (eg, school, work place, neighborhood,bar?).11
Despite the fact that social participation
is critical to the success of community reintegration, the literature
in this area
has not been systematically collated and
synthesized previously, to our knowledge. Therefore, we performed a
systematic review
and meta-analysis to determine if rehabilitation
interventions improve social participation among stroke survivors based
on
the evidence from randomized controlled trials
(RCTs).
More at link.
No comments:
Post a Comment