Stroke
affects a large number of people, and the subsequent rehabilitation and
care are challenging. In Sweden, as in most high-income countries,
almost all people with stroke are cared for at special stroke units (
Riksstroke, 2015).
There are evidence-based guidelines for the care provided at stroke
units, such as early and individual-based mobilization, frequent and
accurate assessment of health status, and well-developed teamwork (
Ringelstein et al., 2013;
Stroke Unit Trialists’ Collaboration [SUTC], 2013).
However, despite the fact that studies in other fields show that the
physical environment is important and can influence the patient’s health
outcomes and how care is provided (
Ulrich et al., 2008),
little is known about the physical environment’s contribution to the
quality of care at stroke units. In this study, we describe how patients
experience the physical environment at a stroke unit that has been
rebuilt according to a new single-room design. Such an investigation is
important because the majority of new healthcare facilities are built
with a predominantly single-room design (
Joint Commission, 2018).
Recently, a study showed that patients in a newly built stroke unit
with a single-room design spend more time being inactive and alone
compared to patients in an older multibed room design (
Anåker, von Koch, Sjöstrand, Bernhardt, & Elf, 2017). However, how patients experience being cared for in single-room units remains unexplored.
As
an important part of the rehabilitation process at stroke units, the
physical environment has recently been highlighted as an important
factor in stimulating both cognitive and social activities among
patients (
Janssen et al., 2014;
White, Bartley, Janssen, Jordan, & Spratt, 2015). According to
Harris, McBride, Ross, and Curtis (2002),
the physical environment can be described as the ambient environment
(e.g., lighting, noise levels, and air quality); architectural features
(e.g., layout of hospital); the size and shape of rooms and placement of
windows; and interior design features (e.g., furnishing and artwork).
All dimensions are important for supporting care and helping patients
return to health and well-being. In nursing, the concept of the
environment has traditionally been referred to as all that surrounds the
patient; there is constant interaction between the patient and the
environment (
Meleis, 2017).
Ulrich (1991)
argued that to promote well-being, the physical environment should be
designed to support patient care by providing a sense of control, access
to social support, and access to positive distraction. Researchers have
examined several areas in which the physical environment can impact
patients’ health outcomes; it has been found that sound and light (
Huisman, Morales, van Hoof, & Kort, 2012) as well as the ability to experience nature (
Ulrich et al., 2008)
can affect health and well-being. Research has also shown that high
levels of attractiveness, in the form of colorful contemporary
furnishings and artwork, for example, may reduce patients’ anxiety (
Becker & Douglass, 2008).
The physical environment can also provide opportunities for activities
and social interactions, for example, by providing access to communal
areas with books, games, and computers; having access to these
opportunities for interaction can be an important prerequisite for
recovery after a stroke (
Janssen et al., 2014;
White et al., 2015).
Based
on the knowledge that the physical environment can contribute to health
and well-being, the concept of evidence-based design has been
established and is increasingly attracting attention. Evidence-based
design incorporates research to achieve the best possible health
outcomes for patients, staff, and visitors (
Hamilton & Watkins, 2009;
Ulrich, Berry, Quan, & Parish, 2010).
To gain a better understanding of the importance of the physical
environment, individual experiences of the environment need to be
studied further. This need for research applies especially when the
trend is to go exclusively to single rooms.
To
gain a better understanding of the importance of the physical
environment, individual experiences of the environment need to be
studied further.
Around the world, new healthcare environments are built primarily using a single-room design (
Joint Commission, 2018).
Studies have shown that patients treated in single rooms have a lower
incidence of both airborne and contact-related infections (
Simon, Maben, Murrells, & Griffiths, 2016;
Ulrich et al., 2008) and confusions (
Caruso, Guardian, Tiengo, dos Santos, & Junior, 2014) than patients in multibed rooms. Reduced noise levels in single rooms improve communication between patients and staff (
Ulrich et al., 2008).
Studies have also shown that patients appreciate being cared for in
single rooms because these rooms provide a personal sphere without
disturbing elements (
Maben et al., 2015;
Persson, Anderberg, & Ekwall, 2015).
However, the sense of loneliness and isolation that patients experience
as a result of a single-room design compared with multibedded units is
receiving more attention (
Persson et al., 2015:
Singh, Subhan, Krishnan, Edwards, & Okeke, 2016).
The
present study focuses on patients who have suffered a stroke. Stroke
can affect any neurological function, for example, it can cause visual
impairment and memory loss, and it can impact a person’s daily life (
Elf, Eriksson, Johansson, von Koch, & Ytterberg, 2016;
Langhorne, Bernhardt, & Kwakkel, 2011). Shortly after a stroke, increased engagement in physical activities targeting mobility may result in reduced impairment (
Veerbeek et al., 2014).
To
live independently and manage their daily lives at home, all stroke
patients should be treated in stroke units. A stroke unit is an
organized and highly specialized unit that provides complete care for
stroke patients and constitutes a geographically defined unit in the
hospital (
SUTC, 2013).
A person who receives care in a stroke unit is less likely to have
complications caused by immobility, such as venous thromboembolism or
chest infections, compared to a patient who receives care in a general
ward (
Govan, Langhorne, & Weir, 2007).
The care at stroke units focuses on acute medical interventions and
early rehabilitation, which are provided by a multiprofessional team (
Riksstroke, 2015). Stroke guidelines recommend starting rehabilitation early to regain functions such as the abilities to walk, talk, and read (
Ringelstein et al., 2013;
SUTC, 2013).
Research
on patients at stroke units has focused mainly on aspects such as where
patients spend their days as well as the types of activities and
interactions they engage in (
Bernhardt, Dewey, Thrift, & Donnan, 2004;
West & Bernhardt, 2012).
Recently, we had the opportunity to compare patients’ behavior in a
stroke unit before and after the unit underwent reconstruction. The
comparison showed that patients’ activities and interactions varied
between the old and the new units and that these variations could be
related to the difference in design. In the new stroke unit, the
patients spent more time alone in their rooms, were less active, and had
fewer interactions compared with the patients in the old unit. One
explanation could be the transformation from mainly multibed rooms to
single rooms (
Anåker et al., 2017).
Nevertheless, we need a deeper understanding of how the physical
environment affects patients and the quality of care at stroke units (
Campbell, Roland, & Buetow, 2000).
A well-designed physical environment can be defined as an environment
that can contribute to social, psychological, spiritual, physical, and
behavioral care (
Jonas & Chez, 2004).
However, the physical environment’s design and its impact on health and
care are rarely the focus of the studies conducted at stroke units.
In
summary, a well-designed, stimulating, and attractive healthcare
environment is a key factor in patient care. Observations of patients’
activities and interactions during stroke care are important; however,
such studies do not reveal how patients experience an environment and
what meaning they give to that environment. How patients experience the
physical environment in stroke units in general, and stroke units with
single-room designs in particular, remains unknown. The aim of this
study was to explore patients’ experiences of the physical environment
at a newly built stroke unit, and the knowledge generated by this
investigation can inform the design of new stroke units.
In summary, a well-designed, stimulating, and attractive healthcare environment is a key factor in patient care.